While it might be tempting zu find a tracking device that works without a subscription, it is best to know what to expect indigenous it. Below are ns strengths und weaknesses of each type of existing product.

Du schaust: Gps tracker ohne sim test



What kommen sie think of the subscription-free Sigfox und Lora gps trackers?


How subscription-free Sigfox und Lora gps trackers work

Sigfox and Lora are two neu networks that oase emerged zu accompany die development of connected objects. Die principle is as follows: use open frequencies (to i m sorry everyone kann connect) whose bandwidth consumes much less battery und data than a classic telephone network.

As this frequencies room open, they do notfall cost any money to operate zum the network service providers (Sigfox and Lora), apart from die equipment itself (installation von antennas to startseite a national territory). The rates offered zu manufacturers are thus extremely interesting. That is what allows manufacturers kommen sie provide general practitioners trackers there is no subscription or with subscription consisted of during the zuerst years von use (this is the case, zum example, des the French firm Invoxia).

Furthermore, die low battery usage helps kommen sie limit the size von the battery, und therefore des the subscription-free tracker that provides. That ist how we acquire attractive offers von miniature gps tracker without a subscription. Attractive but...

Limitations des GPS collars zum cats and dogs there is no a subscription

It is essential zu take right into account the a shed cat or dog might continue kommen sie move approximately while us are looking for it. It is, therefore, essential to oase real-time general practitioners tracking. However, Sigfox und Lora networks do not meet this requirement.

As we have seen, die frequencies provided are public. That results an a limited number von geographical positions reported every hour (everyone can connect, i m sorry clogs up ns network und saturates it, deswegen there zu sein a restricted number des messages determined for each connected device).

Moreover, this saturation leads to delays bei the processing von messages sent von the tracker. Therefore, each position displays through a minimal delay des 1 zu 2 minutes.

Let's take die case des a GPS collar weil das cats and dogs without a subscription the we oase been may be to prüfen (and whose feuer we möchte keep silent). If freundin lose her pet, it möchte take 3 minutes zum the tracker kommen sie send a position, then hinweisen least one more minute kommen sie finally see it shown on her phone display (this minute kann regularly reach 15 minutes). Ns question climate arises as zu how much a disoriented animal tun können travel an 4 minutes... Finding the again will be difficult, notfall to say impossible, even in the case des a chipped or tattooed animal.

Finally, it zu sein essential to specify that ns time taken kommen sie transmit gps positions kann sein lead to ns loss of messages if the haustiere moves. It is, therefore, feasible that freundin may no longer be able to track your pet weil das several minute or also hours. That is not yes, really what we can call a reassuring product zum the safety von your dog or cat. The belästigung is moreover die same for a kid (whether it ist a general practitioners tracker or a kid's smart watch) or a loved one who travel regularly; real-time should constantly be the norm zum the geolocation of a life being.

The separation, personal, instance case von GPS trackers weil das cars und motorbikes

We firmly insist on the fact the we are talking about die GPS tracking von animals because ns same technology can be completely unsuitable weil das one use und perfectly suited to another.

That ist the case for Sigfox and Lora whose connectivity ist ideal for a car or motorbike anti-theft device. Bei this details situation, it zu sein not dramatic to oase a slim shift bei the geolocation des the vehicle; ns essential point here ist not kommen sie track die movements however rather to know ns destinations of the vehicle or motorbike (they will eventually avoid moving).

If your car gets stolen, you möchte then understand where that is and be able kommen sie notify ns police. The advantage des Sigfox and Lora möchte be kommen sie offer a tracker adapted to cars and motorbikes, deswegen you won't have to take the bug out des your vehicle too often kommen sie recharge it. We consider this zu be the best option zum a gps tracker for cars or motorbikes.

Users are notfall mistaken around this. Look at die two Invoxia commodities on amazonas (GPS Tracker for car, motorbike, bag & haustier Tracker, Activity tracking & GPS weil das animals). The two commodities receive opposed scores zum the very same technology and the same manufacturer. Only the use is different.

What about GPS tracker weil das bikes?

As with general practitioners trackers zum car und motorcycle, it ist not dramatic to have slight geolocation delays when trying kommen sie track a bike. Bei the case, ns bike it s okay stolen, it möchte stop relocating thus will allow you kommen sie get that position.

Also, a new generation des smart bikes ist now marketed with a range of features such as bike alarms, locks and trackers. This is, zum example, die case of the Cowboy bike that consists of a gps tracker. Zum this new generation von bicycles, ns anti-theft an equipment integrated to the hardware is usually sufficient.

In ns case von a bike the doesn't oase tracking features integrated, Sigfox und Lora connectivity ist more than enough to prevent the theft des your bike.

What about Bluetooth general practitioners trackers (or associated keychain)?


How connected keychain work

Anti-loss keychains are die smallest trackers on ns market, with the most autonomy. That ist a promising start. They kommen sie with Bluetooth general practitioners technology. However then, exactly how does Bluetooth work?

The Bluetooth general practitioners receiver doesn't come with other technology. No gps antenna, nor general practitioners module, nor simkarte card, nor even wifi. Kommen sie locate chin it wollen communicate with your phone, if that Bluetooth ist on, und retrieve the GPS lage if the GPS ist on.

That functions because die maximum range of such a tracker zu sein 50 meters (in bei open environment, free von any wall surface or obstacle), which enables it kommen sie get ns position von your call which ist inevitably next zu him.

There is, therefore, a situation des dependency des the Bluetooth keychain with another device: if no call communicates v it, it wollen be unable to obtain a location.

Many manufacturers have released Bluetooth general practitioners trackers bei recent years, among which we can cite ns American brands: Tile or Trackr, and the French brand: Wistiki.

Limitations des a connected keychain

The taste issue with this kind of product is the dependency we schutz just mentioned zu other devices: it ist not a stand-alone gps tracker. Outside des the range of your phone, it will be unable to geolocate her cat or dog, which is the very situation bei which you wollen need it the most.

Manufacturers of Bluetooth keychains oase therefore introduced the so-called "crowd GPS" or "community GPS" kommen sie address this concern. The idea is to rely on all ns people who oase the same Bluetooth gps receiver as you (which raises the question des how big zu sein the community). Thus, if one von these human being walks von your cat or dog (equipped through a Bluetooth chip) und if the personen has ns GPS und Bluetooth des its call switched on, just then ns position des your haustier will be updated using the geolocation des this very same person's phone. An other words, too numerous conditions weil das such a linked keychain to work.

Besides, knowing that more and more people are transforming off their phone's gps and/or Bluetooth kommen sie preserve its battery, this reduces more your chances von finding your missing pet. Die hope zu sein even diluent if sie take into account the total absence des real-time tracking des this type of product (because once the community member ist gone, sie will have to wait zum another member to pass von to gain a neu location).

Mehr sehen: Vw Golf 6 16 102 Ps Probleme, Mire Figyelj, Ha Volkswagen Golf 5

The individual case des locators von objects or keys

Taking right into account die use-case a person has for its associated keychain, it is possible kommen sie change opinion ~ above this kind of trackers without a subscription. Therefore our opinion ~ above Wistiki or Trackr möchte differ if you use ns tracker for your haustiere or your keys.

It will notfall be safe zum your cat or dog. On the other hand, it kann sein be advantageous if you're forgetful and often forget where you've save on computer your keys or wallet. You wollen be may be to runde the bell for the lost object in question and will quickly uncover it if it ist at a reasonable distance (in theory 50 meter but beyond 25 meter this möchte rarely work).

It ist even possible zu find your phone that has herbst behind the sofa von using the object locator itself (it has a taste that wollen make her phone ring).

In short, linked keychains are more comfort products (or also gadgets) than safety products.

Other types of GPS trackers there is no a subscription


It's hard kommen sie go into einzelheiten about every type des GPS tracker there is no a subscription there is no boring sie or being long. Yet we wanted kommen sie mention two other options: radio GPS zum cats or dogs and GPS trackers without sim karte cards.

What kommen sie think des radio GPS for cats or dogs?

Radiofrequency GPS arbeiten similarly to tracking collars used zum hunting. A receiver und a transmitter both communicate von radio frequency, over a maximum range of about one kilometre.

That gift a similar issue kommen sie connected keychains, i.e. Ns distance limit. Beyond a details distance, you wollen no longer be able zu locate your pet. GPS tracking works an real-time, but freundin will not be able zu use your mobile phone to track your dog or cat, only the radio receiver wollen do. At the same time, this limits ns number von potential users on the same account zu one person.

We do notfall recommend this type of real-time gps tracker without a subscription; other than perhaps weil das specific cases such as use an dense forests where ns telephone network zu sein almost non-existent.

What kommen sie think des GPS trackers without a simkarte card?

At last, general practitioners trackers there is no a sim karte card are another type des subscription-free trackers. It works nur like gadgets with subscription except that the manufacturer doesn't provide the sim card. That zu sein a positive facet since you have the freedom kommen sie choose the sim karte card und operator yourself.

However, this simkarte card möchte only benefit from a einzel network (unlike integrated simkarte cards i m sorry usually startseite several countries und several operators bei the very same territory). Dafür be careful an less-covered areas where ns network connection des your gps tracker möchte suffer indigenous this minimal number of operators.

The manufacturers von these low-cost trackers are largely Chinese. There zu sein no service attached to the product, which way that freundin will oase no cell phone application (GPS monitor only works through sms request, for example) and no after-sales service. Also, note that the accessories are notfall very pet-friendly.

In short, this is a back-up option weil das the geolocation of a automobile or motorbike. Yet even bei this case, prefer a Sigfox or Lora tracker, which has far better battery life.

Why pick a gps tracker through a subscription?


Choosing the right general practitioners collar zum your dog or cat ist indeed complicated. After ~ all, prior to comparing the various commodities available, you erste need kommen sie have bei idea des which technology zu choose. We schutz tried kommen sie explain below why gps trackers there is no a subscription are not in option kommen sie consider, yet then why gps collars v a subscription would be a better option? Here space some des the advantages des this type von product.

Why carry out these gps collars work with a subscription?

The characteristic of this type des GPS chips is that they include a sim karte card, combined into ns product und sold v it. This sim karte card requires ns manufacturer to enable a phone call line zum each an equipment sold. That describes why a subscription is required kommen sie access die service.

This simkarte card ist almost constantly multi-operator and multi-country. Within the same country, it will be able kommen sie connect to the various national operators (limiting ns risk of in area not being covered), und it will also allow you kommen sie bring her tracker abroad.

Note that die multi-country möglichkeit may be essential if you live close zu a border and the network alternates betwee your country und the neighbour country.

Real-time gps tracking

The sim karte card allows die tracker kommen sie remain connected to the manufacturer's server at all times. Bei other words, it wollen be able kommen sie send its GPS position continuously and thus guarantee real-time tracking von your pet, when being really easy zu use.

You tun können thus gain a lage every 10 seconds; a real benefit wie man your dog or cat has actually disappeared. These frequently updated locations enable you kommen sie track your pet's motions directly from your phone, in real-time, there is no waiting countless minutes betwee each position update.

That is, according to us, the essential point zu consider during your decision at ns time of your purchase. A living being zu sein continuously on die move, even more dafür if ns dog or cat is lost or frightened; zu be able to find it quickly, you need to oase continuously updated info at her disposal.

GPS verfolgung with no street limit

A gps tracker with a sim card has the advantage von being fully independent: it möchte be able kommen sie communicate its lage wherever it is, listed there ist a GSM network.

For the same reasons, it wollen work without any kind of distance limit. That means that your dog or cat can be kilometres away from you without affecting her ability to follow that movements.

Most gps trackers with a subscription zum cats and dogs even work bei about a hundreds countries weist no extra cost.

Mehr sehen: Florian Silbereisen Helene Fischer 2021 / 2022, Florian Silbereisen And Helene Fischer: The Ex

Geolocation the comes with other features

Finally note that gps trackers with subscription advantage from ns strength des the 2G network: tun können send unlimited data und make phone call calls. Bei addition zu real-time tracking, this makes it possible zu offer advanced features such as sound alert or vibrations, which möchte prove useful for the education des your dog or cat, zum example.